The blog ·

Most men who are loudest in a room are often also the most scared in that room

There is a study I came across that tracked voice chats in 163 games of Halo 3. Researchers played identical prerecorded messages in male and female voices and watched what happened. Lower-skilled male players were consistently more hostile toward female voices. More aggressive. More dismissive. The higher-skilled players? They were friendlier toward women. More supportive. Calmer.

Most men who are loudest in a room are often also the most scared in that room: Jan-Willem van der Heiden, relationship coach

The researchers put it down to evolutionary psychology. Men who were losing, who felt their status slipping, lashed out at whoever represented the lowest threat to their ego. The women weren't the problem. The man's own inadequacy was the problem. She just happened to be nearby.

I think about this a lot in the context of relationships.

When your man gets irritable for no clear reason, snaps at something small, withdraws after a moment where he didn't perform the way he wanted, that is the same mechanism. Not identical, but the same root. A man who doesn't feel capable tends not to sit quietly with that feeling. He externalizes it. And the person closest to him absorbs it.

This is not an excuse. A man who can't regulate himself is a man who hasn't done the uncomfortable work of learning what is actually going on inside him. I know because I was that man in certain seasons of my life. My wife has been on the receiving end of my emotional incompetence.

That low-grade friction that fills a room when a man is losing some internal battle and has no language for it.

What the study also tells you, quietly, is what emotional regulation actually produces. The skilled players weren't being noble. They weren't performing generosity. They just had less to prove. Security changes behavior. A man who knows who he is, who isn't scrambling for status, doesn't need to diminish anyone. He has enough room to be kind.

That is what you're actually feeling when you're with a regulated man. Not that he's perfect. Not that he never struggles. But that his struggles don't become your problem to manage. There is a difference between a man who has hard days and a man who makes his hard days your emotional labor.

One is human. The other is a pattern you shouldn't normalize.

Jan-Willem van der Heiden
Jan-Willem van der Heiden

Relationship coach. 8 years and 1,000+ men, then couples. I live in Ubud with my wife and our daughter. More about me or take the relationship quiz.

PreviousMost women are attracted to a man with his life together