The blog ·

There's a line I read in a Japanese book thatI still remember to this day:

"To argue and win is to break down the reality of the person you are arguing against."

There's a line I read in a Japanese book thatI still remember to this day:: Jan-Willem van der Heiden, relationship coach

You can be right. Completely right. You can have the facts, the receipts, the timeline. You can win the argument so cleanly there's nothing left to say.

And in doing so, you can quietly dismantle the person across from you. Their sense of themselves.

Most couples don't fight about what they think they're fighting about. They fight about who gets to be real. Whose version of events counts. Whose perception is allowed to stand.

Winning an argument with your partner doesn't just close the case. It tells them that their experience of reality is wrong. That they can't be trusted to read a room, remember a moment, or understand what's happening between you. Do that enough times and their self confidence ebbs.

I've done this. My wife has done this. Anyone honest enough to look back on their relationship has done this. The goal in the moment is to be right. The cost, which you only see later, is connection.

This isn't about letting things go that matter. It isn't about swallowing what's true. It's about understanding that how you land your truth is part of the deal. A partner who feels consistently defeated in conversation with their partner doesn't become more open. They become quieter. More distant. More managed.

That distance you feel isn't indifference. It's protection.

The book says to be kind even if you are right. Especially if you are right. Because that's when the power is entirely yours, and what you do with power in an intimate relationship is either the beginning or the end of something.

Jan-Willem van der Heiden
Jan-Willem van der Heiden

Relationship coach. 8 years and 1,000+ men, then couples. I live in Ubud with my wife and our daughter. More about me or take the relationship quiz.

PreviousMost women are optimising for the wrong signal